Kennan
Playbook

How to negotiate a salary offer.

You got the offer. The recruiter has named a number. The next thirty seconds determine the next year's compensation. Most candidates lose money here not because they negotiate badly, but because they negotiate fast — out of relief, gratitude, or the urge to "not be that person."

This is the move-by-move playbook for the conversation between a verbal offer and a signed letter, built from three named frameworks from negotiation research: anchoring, tactical empathy, and STAR for justifying the anchor.

When salary is most negotiable

The window where salary is most negotiable is between the verbal offer and the signed letter. Inside that window:

  • Your perceived market value is at its peak — they want you
  • The hiring manager has already committed internally
  • The recruiter's incentive aligns with closing, not negotiating you down
  • You have leverage you will never have again with this employer

Outside that window — once you have started, or once you have signed — every percentage point costs more political capital.

Step 1 — Do not accept on the call

The recruiter will ask "what do you think?" or "is this in the range you were looking for?" The reflex move is to thank them and accept. The correct move is to take twenty-four to forty-eight hours.

Specifically:

Thank you, this is exciting. I want to give the offer the consideration it deserves, so let me come back to you tomorrow with any questions.

That is it. No counter on the spot. The pause shifts the conversation from "is this enough" to "how do we make this work."

Step 2 — Anchor with a precise number, defended

When you come back, you anchor. From the anchoring framework:

  • Use a precise number, not a round one ($182,500, not $180,000)
  • Anchor with a range that bolsters upward ($182,500 to $198,000, not a midpoint)
  • Move first if the information is on your side
  • Justify with one externally verifiable signal

A precise number implies you have done the math. The justification gives the counter something to negotiate against other than your wish.

Step 3 — Defuse their counter with tactical empathy

If they push back, the reflex is to defend. The correct move is to label, then ask a calibrated question. From tactical empathy:

It sounds like there is a band you are trying to fit me into. How is that band typically built — comparables, internal pay scale, level expectations?

This pulls information you will use in the next round. The recruiter has just told you the lever to pull.

Step 4 — Negotiate non-cash compensation

If base is genuinely capped, the negotiation is not over. Equity, signing bonus, RSU refresh, deferred review, more vacation, remote flexibility — all real money. Ask:

Understood on the base band. What flexibility do we have on the equity grant, the signing bonus, or an early review at six months?

An early review at six months is often easier to give than a $10,000 base bump and worth the same over a two-year horizon.

Step 5 — Be willing to walk

Anchoring without an exit is wishful. Before you make any move, know:

  • Your walk-away point (the offer where you say no and mean it)
  • Your alternative (other offers, the option to stay, contract work, taking a beat)

If you cannot walk, you are not negotiating. You are asking.

Sample dialogue

Recruiter: "We can do $175,000 base. How does that sound?"

You: "Thank you — I want to give the offer the consideration it deserves. Let me come back to you tomorrow with any questions."

— next day —

You: "I think $182,500 to $198,000 base is where I would expect this role to land, given scope and comparable senior offers I have seen. Is there room to work in that range?"

Recruiter: "Honestly, that is higher than our band for this level."

You: "It sounds like there is a band you are trying to fit me into. How is that band typically built — comparables, internal pay scale, level expectations? I want to make sure I am reading what is actually flexible."

Common pitfalls

  1. Counter-anchoring with a round number. $200,000 reads as a wish; $198,500 reads as a calculation. Use the calculation.
  2. Defending instead of exploring. When they push back, your reflex is to justify your anchor. The better move is one calibrated question that surfaces what is actually flexible.
  3. Forgetting non-cash compensation. Equity, signing bonus, RSU refresh, deferred review, more vacation — all negotiable, often easier to give than base.
  4. Showing relief. Once you signal relief, the negotiation ends. Stay measured even if the offer is great.

Get this on a HUD only you can see.

Kennan is the real-time AI meeting assistant for Mac. When the recruiter says "we can do $175,000," the assistant surfaces the next thing to say, in the same format as the dialogue above. Join the waitlist to get notified at launch.

For macOS. A lifetime license, pay once at launch. We only email when Kennan ships.